Rabbis Honored at the 58th Annual Four Champlain’s Brotherhood Event

Capital District’s Jewish War Veterans Present 58th Annual Four Chaplains Brotherhood Award

Rabbis Linda Motzkin & Jonathan Rubenstein honored on the 80th Anniversary of the loss of the Four Chaplains

SCHENECTADY, N.Y. – Members of the Jewish War Veterans across the Capital District Council joined with Albany Post 105 of the JWV to remember the service and sacrifice of the Four Chaplains of World War II and present their 58th annual Brotherhood Award to Rabbis Jonathan Rubenstein and Linda Motzkin of Saratoga Springs on Sunday, March 5, 2023 at the First Reformed Church of Schenectady.

For more than a half century, the annual event has honored the four Army chaplains who gave their lives in the sinking of the troopship Dorchester on February 3, 1943. The presentation of the Brotherhood Award honors those whose services and devotion in the practice of brotherhood are deserving of community recognition.

“We honor people who, in their lifetime, have shown and given the type of selfless service that is commensurate with the legacy of the Four Chaplains,” said Fred Altman, Albany Post 105 commander during the award presentation.

The Four Chaplains aboard the Dorchester included Reverend George Fox, a Methodist minister from Lewiston, Penn., Rabbi Alexander Goode from Brooklyn, Dutch Reformed Reverend Clark Poling, from Schenectady, and Father John Washington, a Roman Catholic priest from Newark, N.J.

The ship was torpedoed shortly before 1 a.m. on February 3, 1943. The chaplains provided comfort and direction to Soldiers as the ship rapidly sank. They gave up their own life jackets to others and calmly prayed as the ship slipped under the North Atlantic waters.

“The ceremony, representing the selfless service and courage of the Four Chaplains on the torpedoed and sinking SS Dorchester in January 1943, takes place at the former pulpit of one of those immortal chaplains, Clark Poling’s First Reformed Church in Schenectady,” said Past Post 105 Commander Lance Allen Wang.

The Jewish War Veterans have held an annual ceremony to remember the Four Chaplains and recognize those who live up to their legacy since 1966, Altman said, three years before even the national Four Chaplains Memorial Foundation established their own annual award event.

The rabbis, a married couple who retired January 1st from Temple Sinai in Saratoga Springs after 36 years, had been co-rabbis serving the Jewish community of Saratoga as it grew from around 60 to 190 families.

More than 80 representatives from across the community attended the program, including Gold Star Mothers, veterans organizations, representatives of the First Reformed Church, the Jewish Federation of Northeastern New York, Capital District Jewish Community Centers, members of the New York State Assembly, New York State Senate, the region’s congressional representative, Congressman Paul Tonko and the mayor of Saratoga Springs, Ron Kim.

“Each year we talk about the legacy of the Four Chaplains as ‘unity without uniformity,” to highlight that as Americans, we can and must work together, across our differences, whether it be our faiths or our politics to do better,” Altman said.

Beyond their service to their congregation and community, Rabbis Motzkin and Rubenstein each pursued efforts to assist and support those most in need.

Rabbi Rubenstein led Temple Sinai’s Slice of Heaven bakery project, a non-profit bakery operated from the synagogue’s kitchen which continues to produce baked goods to help those less fortunate.

Rabbi Motzkin, one of only 13 female scribes in the world, initiated the Community Torah Project, a long-term process of making a Torah scroll, involving more than 4,000 participants in the U.S. and internationally.

The two combined their work in a project known as Bread and Torah in 2004 and share their passions with interactive educational programs around the world. The couple have been educators and ambassadors of goodwill to 15 states and Washington, D.C., and to Jewish communities in Mexico, Argentina, Chile, South Africa, New Zealand, Hungary, and Poland.

“We accept this award with deep humility, gratitude and a sense of honor,” said Rabbi Rubenstein.

“I can honestly say that I don’t know what I would have done on the deck of the Dorchester on that fateful night,” Rubenstein said. “And not knowing that, it motivates me to the best I can.”

Rabbi Motzkin drew parallels to the visual of the Four Chaplains, holding hands together in their individual faith, to support each other.

Motzkin said the couple just returned from a trip to Israel where they visited a local school for both Israeli and Palestinian Arab children.

The program is called hand in hand, Motzkin said, and she couldn’t help but draw the parallel to the Four Chaplains.

The school provides bilingual, integrated education to more than 2,000 students enrolled in six Hand in Hand schools from Jerusalem to the Galilee, she said.

Yad B’yad, hand in hand, we embrace each other for strength and progress, as the Four Chaplains did for each other and the Soldiers they served on the Dorchester, Motzkin said.

“I am humbled. I’m very aware of everything we’ve done in 36 years,” she said.  “But this award is really accepted in the name of all of you, who we have been blessed to join hands with for all these years.”

“So much hand in hand work is never acknowledged in our community,” Motzkin said, “We’re all working hand in hand, and that is perhaps the lasting legacy of the Four Chaplains.”

“The Capital District of JWV New York executed an outstanding Four Chaplains memorial service and recognition ceremony,” said Gary Ginsburg, the senior vice commander for the Jewish War Veterans Department of New York. “I extend my sincere thanks all the people involved, to include the members of JWV Posts 105, 106, 36 and 401.”

Story by Richard Goldenberg, Capital District Council Commander, JWV

All photos are courtesy of the Jewish War Veterans.